The
state of the state had some good, some bad and some funny points last night.
Education testing scores for are up. Of course this is a huge overview but it showed some hope. One issue I and other legislators had is the governor now wants to remove the testing standards for our children. People have to wonder why.
One of the first funny points of the night was When the Phil was talking about the wonders of pre K, Bill Dunn began to hold up and shake the governors own report on Pre K. Now when these reports are made they are usually a "flacks only need apply" type job. They reports usually cost millions and end up saying what ever the governor wants them to say. Not so for this report. The results for pre K?
Testing scores went DOWN for kids who went to pre K! Now he wants to expand the program. Doesn't he care about the children?
Another funny point came when the Phil started to talk about education and "Needs based" Funding. This is funding that says if you are poor you are less intelligent and can't learn. It says that access will equil success (I think the study on pre K will tell that tale but any way).
Here is what Phil said when talking about pre K last night.
Let me address one issue head on. I have followed some of the discussion about halting the further funding of pre-K insofar as it serves any children other than the poor, the so-called “at-risk” students. This would be a terrible mistake, and I ask those of you who are espousing this to reconsider.
How do you say to a middle class family with children in the public schools: “Yes you pay taxes for these classrooms; yes, they are public schools; but no, those classrooms aren’t open to your children?”
I hope to live to see the day when we stop dividing our children up into poor and rich. These are all God’s children, these are all America’s and Tennessee’s children; we run the schools, they are public schools, they are a public responsibility, they need to be open to the public. OK, he is against needs based standards for education right?
Not 60 seconds later he said this.....
The budget that I am proposing also contains two changes to the lottery scholarship program. I believe in the merit concept behind the Hope scholarships.......And then the big but.
.......I have proposed in this budget that we take about half of the unallocated lottery reserves, $200 million specifically, and use it to establish an endowment for TSAC. Between the earnings from this endowment and a small additional appropriation from the annual lottery surplus, we will be able to assist financially another 12-15,000 deserving and hard-working Tennessee students to earn a college education. That is a NEEDS BASED PROGRAM!! The conservatives over where I sit were about rolling out! A classic Flip flop in the same speech! Got to love it!
Of course many of the people who are lawyers in the legislators do not think it is even constitutional. I am sure Phil will get an AGs opinion to say what ever he wants but this one is going to be tough as to how they can legally make it fit in
what is allowed. We will see.
Some of us chuckled again about the idea of Phil pushing to take drivers licences away from drunk drivers. While a good idea, With the number of run ins with the law involving alcohol and democrat legislators this last year I think Phil may want to put aside some money for legislator bus fairs so he will have the votes to pass the rest of his agenda.
Sen. Diane Black noticed how an idea she has been pushing for at least 4 years (senior choice for at home care)was lifted by the Governor.
Many people laughed as the governor tried to tell a sob story of his mother only being able to stay at home because Phil had a daughter who took care of her.
Phil is worth $300 MILLION. What? He couldn't afford any help? We rolled at that one too.
Any way, it is a good idea.
Many legislators I gathered with last night noticed what was not in the speech.
Nothing at all on working to stop illegal immigration.
Nothing to help fight or lock up the child predators. Even the ones that are in our own schools.
Government employees got a raise. Some people got huge pay raises but the most broad based raise you could give to all Tennesseans would be to cut a tax that every Tennessean pays. The sales tax on food. Nothing about cutting the sales tax on food (or any tax) was mentioned. Even though we have almost the same amount of money we had last year (with the almost two billion dollar surplus). I guess the people building the 20 million dollar party bunker come first.
Phil for another year used the boat analogy. I think it is turning into another episode of "The love boat". The rich friends of Phil get a fun trip around sunny places, none of the important issues to the people of Tennessee ever gets discussed, we wonder around lost at sea and we only see port after eight years.